i think there might be something to the idea that Harry is the horcrux, but it is going to really piss me off if he has to die to kill off the evil of Voldemort. I think Dumbledore is really dead. I think that is going to be necessary for Harry to truly fight the evil himself. I don't think that means Snape is evil- Dumbledore held Harry frozen to watch the event so I think Dumbledore and Snape had it planned. I'm confused why Dumbledore would have wanted to continue Harry's belief that Snape is evil, though, so that is where I get stuck. It would be too easy for Snape to really be a bad guy after all these books of not being sure where his loyalties lie.